- A. Heller
- Anabel Leek
- Ballerinaman
- Big Billy Hill Billy
- Big Red
- Big Tobacco
- Bing
- Blame Thrower
- Bullfighter
- Butch
- Canned Tornado
- Carmine
- Carol
- Casanova Frankenstein
- Casanova Frankenstein's Limo
- Casanova Frankenstein's mansion
- Champion City
- Chloroform-deploying Portable Enticement Snare
- Cold Fusion Ultrasonic Neuro-Stunner
- Disco Boys
- Eddie
- Eddie's Station Wagon
- Electro-Nuclear Magnet
- Enhanced Suit
- Evil Devil Woman
- Frat Boys
- Furriers
- Globalman
- Glue Grenades
- Gorilla
- Hair Dryer
- Heller Fairgrounds
- Herkimer Battle Jitney
- Insane Asylum
- Invisible Boy
- Jeffrey
- Jeffrey's Car
- Jet Pack
- Lance Hunt
- Little Miss Vengence
- Lucille
- Mailman
- Martial Artist
- McGuire
- Media
- Monica
- Mr. Pups
- Mystery Men (Film)
- Mystery Men (Team)
- Mystery Men Wiki
- Not-So-Goodie Mob
- PMS Avenger
- Pencilhead
- Pig (2)
- Pig (3)
- Pointy
- Polyphony Digital inc.
- Powerwoman (First)
- Powerwoman (Second)
- Psycho-frakulator
- Psychotropic Bacterium Dart Launchers
- Radio Man
- Rebecca Beaner
- Red Eyes
- Reporter
- Retirement Center
- Reverse Psychologist
- Roland
- Roy
- Sally
- Sally's Auto Dismantlers
- Shrinker
- Smith
- Son of Pencilhead
- Squeegee Man
- Stilt Man
- Sub Micronic Laser
- Suits
- Supervacman
- Susies
- Technology
- The Artiste
- The Sphinx
- The Spleen
- Thirstyman
- Tony C.
- Tony P's Car
- Tony Pompadour
- Tracy
- Victor Weems
- Violet
- Waffler